CONNERSVILLE, INDIANA (The Daily Whatever Press) — Asked at a candidate forum what unpopular decision she’d make if elected to the Fayette County Council, Jaime West gave the only answer in the history of candidate forums anyone has ever remembered.
“Firing all Republicans.”
She did not stop there, because she is Jaime West and she had no notes. Like, literally, she had no notes. “I wouldn’t let them. I mean, I don’t even talk to them. I don’t like them.” Then, being fair: “There are good Republicans out there.” The MAGA ones, though, she called “racist” and “not very intelligent.” And when the moderator asked for her closing message to the voters of District 4, in a county where she says people have threatened her life, she thought it over and said, “We have guns too.”
Don’t believe me? Watch it for yourself:
The forum ran Friday, October 9, on LocalTV3, co-sponsored by the Connersville News-Examiner, whose managing editor, Amy Graham-McCarty, moderated with the composure of a woman who has moderated a great many things in Fayette County and never once this. West’s segment starts about thirty-three minutes in. By Tuesday, the clip was on Mediaite, the New York Post, Breitbart, the Blaze, TMZ, and, naturally, Libs of TikTok, which posted it with the caption “This is NOT a skit.” By midweek, BuzzFeed counted 8.2 million people engaging with it. The whole county has about 23,000.
Who she is
Jaime West is a mother of three grown kids. She owns Queen Bee’s Cleaning LLC. She delivers groceries and packages around Fayette County for a living, and she said so on camera like it was the most normal credential in the world, because it is. She opened by saying she had no prepared statement and would speak “from my heart,” and then she did exactly that for several minutes, and the heart in question turned out to have opinions about ICE “coming into our communities, stealing people’s jobs.” Yes, mama!
She came to clean house, and instead she won the hearts of every fed-up red state Democrat in the country. Hell, I live in Indiana, and if it didn’t mean voter fraud (which isn’t prevalent and always seems to be a Trump voter, anyways), I would drive a couple hours south and vote for this hero myself.
Her Republican opponent, Gary Keener Jr., did not attend. He had “prior business commitments,” so he sent a statement for the moderator to read aloud, and it said he had “never been more excited and committed to work diligently and tirelessly” to spend tax dollars efficiently and broaden the tax base. Graham-McCarty read it. I assume she read it well. Nobody has posted a clip of it, because nobody has ever posted a clip of a tax-base statement, anywhere, ever.
So that is the matchup in District 4: one candidate who showed up with nothing but herself, and one candidate who sent a fax from 1991.
What the outrage machine thought it was doing
Fayette County went for Trump by about 77 percent in 2024. There is no public polling on this race, because there is never public polling on a county council race, because until last Friday nobody outside Fayette County knew it had a council. The right-wing content industry found the clip and did what it does: it tried to turn a woman who cleans houses in Connersville into a national exhibit of Democratic derangement. Libs of TikTok asked whether she was intoxicated. Blaze Media’s Steve Baker decided she was “clearly drunk or high.” Zero Hedge got involved, which is how you know a story has reached the part of the internet where everyone is a doctor.
Nothing has been confirmed. Not one of the people diagnosing her was in the room, and I am not going to be the forty-thousandth guy on the internet with a medical opinion about a stranger in a thirty-second clip. What I will say is that the people clutching their pearls hardest over “We have guns too” are the same people who spent the last decade posting family portraits where everyone, including the toddler, is holding an AR-15. A Hoosier Democrat says one sentence about the Second Amendment, and suddenly the Come and Take It crowd needs a fainting couch. SHUDDER
Then the plan backfired, because the internet does not work the way the Blaze thinks it works. Viva Frei, a Canadian lawyer who is nobody’s idea of a lefty, posted “This is WILD” and got 1.6 million views. Juliegrace Brufke, who covers Capitol Hill, called it “the most entertaining candidate interview” of the cycle. Ryan Grim posted the clip with “Watch this to the end, you won’t regret it.” Mike Nellis, a Democratic strategist who has run actual campaigns with actual budgets, said, “This is the greatest thing I’ve ever seen.” Jim Stewartson said, “I adore this lady.” And in the group chat of every Democrat who has ever lived in a red county, a single text went out: “Oh my God, she’s me.”
The sheriff has entered the chat
The topper came Tuesday. During the forum, West said that “the sheriff’s nephew threatened to blow my head off.” FOX59 called Fayette County Sheriff Zac Jones, who said he has never met her and does not have a nephew. He has five nieces. He has zero nephews.
Somewhere in Fayette County there is either a different sheriff, a very intimidating niece, or a case of mistaken identity that would take Rosco P. Coltrane a full episode to untangle. I would watch that episode, wouldn’t you?
Why I am so happy
I live in Fort Wayne. I have been the only Democrat at a cookout in Allen County, and I have said, after exactly one beer, things I would not want to see on LocalTV3. Every Democrat in a deep-red county has a Jaime West inside them, and most of us keep her in a drawer, because we have to keep going to the cookout. She took hers to a candidate forum, on camera, with no notes, and the right-wing outrage machine spent a week trying to shame her and instead made her the only county council candidate in America anyone can name. The opponent who stayed home got nothing. The woman who showed up got 8.2 million people and a fan club.
Jaime, if you’re listening: maybe bring notes next time. Maybe not. Early voting is open in Indiana, and District 4 gets to decide on November 3 whether it wants the fax-sender or the woman.
Libs of TikTok set out to humiliate a working mom in Connersville and ended up doing her advance work for free, and that, you Punisher-decal patriots, is the funniest thing that has happened in Indiana politics all year, and maybe ever.
Thanks for stopping by!
We’re Dana DuBois and Lawrence Winnerman, lifelong BFFs and co-hosts of The Daily Whatever Show — our independent home for smart, irreverent conversations about culture, politics, media, creativity, relationships, aging, and whatever else is shaping modern life this week.
We’re live every Friday at 10am ET with thoughtful analysis, sharp interviews, cultural commentary, humor, and the kind of conversations that don’t pretend everything is fine when it clearly isn’t.
If you’re enjoying what we’re building, please consider supporting our work with a paid subscription. Your support helps us keep the show independent, book fascinating guests, and continue creating smart conversations with your morning coffee.
We love you — mean it!
YEAH, HARD TO BELIEVE THAT MAGA NAZIS THINK WE ALL ON THE LEFT AREN’T ARMED, YOU SILLYFCKERS.